Kohler Highline vs Cimarron

Kohler Highline vs Cimarron: Which Toilet Design Is Better?

Kohler as a brand has produced some of the best products when in regards to toilets. Highline and Cimarron are both toilet manufacturing lines from this brand, but it may be overwhelming for you to choose one that best suits you.

However, although there are many differences between the two, they also have a few things in common. Kohler Highline is considered much more affordable to you if you are an average homeowner.  Regardless of its lower price than that of Cimarron, Highline is not short of some incredible features.

The Highline models are 1.28, 1.6, and 1.0 Gallons per Flush, implying that it is a very water-efficient toilet. You can also get a Highline toilet with a dual flush for a more powerful flush.

On the other hand, the easy-to-clean one-piece design is one of the most outstanding features of Kohler Cimarron. With that short analysis, let us dive deeper to give you a better acquaintance of both toilets to help you make an informed buying decision. 

Main Differences between Highline vs Cimarron

The main differences between Kohler Highline vs Cimarron are:

  • Highline is available in 1.0, 1.28, or 1.6 GPF, whereas Cimarron is available in 1.28 or 1.6 GPF.
  • Highline comes in a two-piece design only, whereas Cimarron is available in both one- and two-piece designs. 
  • Some Cimarron models have skirted traps, whereas Highline toilets are not skirted because they come in a two-design only.
  • Cimarron is available in seven different colors, whereas with Highline, you can only choose from four colors. 

Highline Overview

Highline is among the top toilet lines from the Kohler brand. The units in this category come in different excellent features to choose from, depending on the toilet you decide to buy. Some of the things that set it apart from its competitors include:


Low prices are a clever way of attracting a huge number of customers. Highline toilets from Kohler are amazingly affordable, especially to an average homeowner who wants to upgrade by replacing an old unit.

However, do not be blinded by the small price tags that these units carry. They are packed with excellent features found on more expensive toilets from the Kohler brand. 

Two-piece Design Only

Regardless of the many outstanding features, one thing that you will not find with Highline toilets is the one-piece design. These units are only available in two-piece design, and this is one of the contributors to their lower price.

Two-piece toilets are cheaper because they are easy to transport and install, unlike one-piece toilets, whose transportation and installation are complicated. However, one-piece units last longer, and they are easy to clean.

The cleaning process for a two-piece toilet is made challenging by the crevices formed when the bowl and tank are joined during installation. This phenomenon is not seen in one-piece units because they come assembled as a single product.  


The main concern that many people are faced with today is acquiring products that have minimal or no negative impact on the environment. One of the best ways to care about the environment is by having water-efficient fixtures in your home, including your toilet.

Highline toilets offer several ways of conserving water, whereby you can choose between three flushing volumes. These volumes are 1.0, 1.28, and 1.6 GPF. The dual-flush system available in these units allows you to select either partial or full flush.

Partial flush is for liquid and lighter waste, while the full flush option offers more power for heavier and solid waste. Such a feature is essential because it allows you to save a lot of water in the long run. 


Kohler Highline toilets can be installed anywhere, in commercial and residential premises. This is because they comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) requirements.

Therefore, seniors and people with mobility issues can use such a unit without straining when sitting on or standing up from it. Above that, Highline toilets feature Comfort Height and elongated bowls, which offer the added convenience of using them. 

Flushing Mechanism

Kohler Highline toilets feature a Class Five flushing system. Such a system is powerful enough to send any amount of waste down the drain without necessarily flushing twice.

The flushing lever is chrome-enameled and located conveniently on the tank’s left side, meaning that you can activate it even while seated. 


  • The installation process is simple.
  • The units are very water-efficient, saving you water and money. This makes Highline toilets APA WaterSense certified.
  • The Class Five flushing system is powerful to have the job done in a single flush.
  • Comfort Height offers more convenience across a wider range of users.
  • Highline toilets are much affordable to an average homeowner, thanks to their low prices.
  • There is a one-year warranty that accompanies these products.


  • The toilet seat and wax ring are not included in the package. You have to purchase them separately.
  • Comfort Height may be too high for short people and small kids.
  • Class Five flushing system may be noisy.
  • Available in two-piece design only.

Cimarron Overview

Although this is another toilet line from the Kohler brand, it has a few features that distinguish it from the Highline. This makes Cimarron carry a heavy price tag, making it a much higher-end toilet. Some of Cimarron’s main features include:

The Design

Cimarron toilets are available in both one- and two-piece designs. One-piece Cimarron toilets are easier to clean. They lack a crevice between the tank and the bowl, which could harbor filth and dirt. Cimarron units also feature skirted traps, which prevent the buildup of nooks and crannies. 


Cimarron toilets are water-efficient, but they rank lower on that compared to Highline units. That is because you will not find a Cimarron toilet that consumes less than 1.28 Gallons per Flush (GPF), unlike some Highline toilets with a 1.0 GPF.

Additionally, Cimarron toilets lack a dual-flush, which is bad news for many buyers considering these products’ high price. 

Elongated Bowl

As mentioned before, elongated bowls offer much more comfort and convenience to toilet users. Like Highline, Cimarron also comes in elongated bowls and Comfort Height, ideal for most adult toilet users and people with mobility issues.

With such a bowl height, sitting on the toilet or standing up from it are made easier. The main issue with an elongated bowl is that it consumes more space than the round/spherical bowl. 


Cimarron toilets are made from vitreous china, a well-known material for its sturdiness, durability, and ease of cleaning. This material is also non-stick, implying that waste particles will not adhere to it.

Therefore, you can be sure that your Cimarron toilet will serve you for quite a long time before it requires any repairs or maintenance.  

AquaPiston Flushing System

Nothing else says toilet power other than its flushing system. Unlike Highline’s Class Five flushing system, the AquaPiston flushing system forces water into the toilet’s bowl from all angles.

Such action sends the waste away almost instantly and gives the toilet bowl a thorough rinse. This is another factor contributing to the cleanliness of Cimarron toilets. 

Color Choices

Unlike Highline, which offers only four color options, Cimarron gives you the freedom to choose from seven colors.  You can go for different finishes, including biscuit, almond, and black.

With such a wide range of colors, you can be certain that Kohler Cimarron toilets match perfectly with different interior décors. 


  • Easy to clean and maintain one-piece design available. There are no crevices between the bowl and tank that house dirt and filth.
  • Powerful AquaPiston flushing system delivers water into the bowl from all angles, getting the job done every time. 
  • Comfortable Height and elongated bowls offer more comfort and convenience to a wider range of toilet users. 
  • Durable, long-lasting, and sturdy vitreous china material used in Cimarron’s manufacture. 
  • The flush is quieter than that of Highline toilets.


  • The toilet seat and supply line must be purchased separately. 
  • Some Cimarron toilets with a 1.6 GPF are not WaterSense approved because they are not water-efficient. 
  • These units are more expensive than their Highline cousins.
  • They lack the dual-flush option.

Which is better between Kohler Cimarron and Highline

As mentioned before, Cimarron and Highline are both major toilet lines from the Kohler brand. This can confuse when homeowners go shopping for a smart toilet.

However, although both Highline and Cimarron are great products, some distinctive characteristics set each of them in its own league. Considering an average homeowner, we can say that Highline is a better choice than Cimarron in so many ways.

First, if you want a toilet that will save you water and money in the long run, Highline has got you covered. 

Some of Highline models consume as little as 1.0 Gallons per Flush, which is relatively low than what other toilets require. Other models in the Highline category use 1.28 and 1.6 Gallons per Flush, implying that they are water efficient, too. Using such little water does not mean that the toilet does not mean that Highline toilets perform any less.

The crucial thing to remember is that using less water does not translate to less performance. Highline toilets with a 1.0 GPF use less water per flush without compromising their performance.

Looking at the flushing system, Highline toilets feature a Class Five system, which is powerful enough to send any amount of waste away in a single flush.

If you want to avoid incurring extra costs in the future, it is important to get a toilet with a powerful flushing system to prevent clogging. The Class Five flushing system in Highline toilets is not as powerful as Cimarron’s AquaPiston system, but it gets the work done perfectly using less water.  

Affordability is another factor that makes Highline the best choice. During these hard times, people are looking for products that are in favor of their budgets.

If you are in that category, then Highline toilets will surely mesmerize you with their prices. These units are available in two-piece design only, unlike Cimarron toilets, which are available in both one- and two-piece designs. Two-piece toilets are cheaper because it is easy to transport them and the installation process is not complicated.

However, the main issue with two-piece toilets is that the cleaning process can sometimes be overwhelming.

During installation, the toilet’s bowl and tank are joined to form a single unit. The aperture created where these two parts join can become a hiding place for dirt, unlike in one-piece toilets where there are no crevices.

Finally, Highline toilets are ADA compliant. Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is a statutory requirement that dictates all toilets must have a seat height of 17 to 19 inches.

This is the height from the floor to the toilet bowl rim and seat. ADA compliant toilets can be installed in commercial and residential premises because they support a wider range of users. Moreover, they are ideal for individuals with mobility issues as they promote a smooth transition from wheelchairs and walkers onto the toilet seat.   


Question: Which is better between round and elongated toilets?

Answer: The majority prefer elongated toilets because they offer more sitting space and comfort. However, round toilets are ideal in bathrooms where space is a constraint. Moreover, round toilet bowls are cheaper than their elongated cousins.

Question: Which is better: Kohler or American Standard?

Answer: Both brands are leaders in the market, and their products have positive and negative sides. Kohler offers more comfort, better designs, and easy-to-clean toilets, but its products are a bit expensive. American Standard offers cheaper toilets with powerful flushing systems. 

Question: Which toilet should I buy between Kohler Highline and Cimarron?

Answer: Kohler Highline is more affordable to an average homeowner, and some of its models consume very little water in a single flush. Cimarron is praised for its powerful flushing system, but it is expensive than Highline and not as water-efficient. 

Question: What do I look for when buying a toilet?

Answer: There are many things to consider, including bowl shape, size, color, and flushing technology. However, there are two primary types of toilets in today’s market: Pressure-assisted and Gravity-feed toilets. Gravity-feed units are the most dominant in the market, but you can also check out pressure-assisted ones. 

Question: What is meant by Class Five flushing?

Answer: Class Five is a type of flushing system found in modern toilets, such as Highline units. The system is designed to send away heavy waste in a single flush using as little water as possible. The system’s large flush valve works together with a direct-fed jet to rapidly release water to maximize its flow. Class Five flushing system pushes waste away and gives the toilet bowl a thorough rinse. 


Cimarron and Highline are both toilet lines from the Kohler brand. The two lines share some specs, but some features set them apart. With the above information, you can see that Highline toilets are far better for an average homeowner than the Cimarron toilets.

That is because they are very affordable, and they perform almost as equally as the Cimarron. Besides their light price tags, you will not incur additional costs in terms of the installation fee. The installation process is quite simple.

You can decide to do it yourself or hire a professional if you don’t have the time. Highline toilets also get the first position for water conservation because some of the models have minimal water consumption, with as low as 1.0 gallons per flush. 

On the flip side, Cimarron toilets are not so water-efficient because none consumes less than 1.28 gallons in every flush. Therefore, if saving water is your main concern, Highline is the best option for you.

If you are not worried about water conservation and want a toilet that features a powerful flush system, Cimarron is your best shot. Otherwise, ensure that you consider the factors in this article to help you make a wise purchase decision.

I believe that the above description has given you enough information for easy head-to-head comparison between Kohler Highline and Cimarron.    

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top